(3) Typical IEEE authors are VERY smart people, with strong analytic skills, powerful abstract thinking ability - people who are very fluent in the language of advanced mathematics. " This practice reduces a paper's page count but makes life miserable for the reader. If you want to know it's origin, derivation, and meaning, see References. They present a equation and figuratively say, "Here's an important equation. (2) Typical IEEE authors skip over necessary technical explanations by referring to previously written papers. Such a rule encourages authors to falsely assume that their readers know everything that the author knows. I suppose they have that rule to reduce the page count of their published papers, but I believe such a rule inhibits the communication of ideas. And their Rule# 1 was: "Do not explain the obvious." I am not joking. (1) The IEEE publications' editors, over the years, have developed editorial standards that inhibit "easy to follow papers." Years ago I read the IEEE Signal Processing Society's "Guidelines for Authors" instructions. When it comes to IEEE-published papers you will see VERY VERY few "papers that are easy to follow and also easy to reproduce in MATLAB." There are three reasons for this sad situation: Sadly, both of the magazine publishers are gone (no longer in business). On the topic of general DSP there used to be two magazines that published, as you say, "papers that are easy to follow and also easy to reproduce in MATLAB." Those magazines were: 'Embedded Systems Programming' magazine and Personal Engineering magazine. I have just one publication in the area of estimation theory. Most likely such papers are IEEE Signal processing letters, IEEE communication letters or some conference papers.Ī) I posted this question on dsp stackexchange and someone suggest 's forums would be a more appropriate place for this.ī) The definition of easy is relative so to give the reader some perspective: I have a Master's in Electrical Engineering (MS-EE) specializing in Digital Systems and Signal Processing. May be such papers will be older but of course latest publications would be preferable. Now what I wanna know is what papers have you come across that seem very easy to follow (and reproduce/simulate) and it' s almost like reading a book?ġ) Detection and Estimation But to me this was the most appropriate example. May be some of the readers don't have IEEE access. Such papers give the beginner level researcher some confidence. I know that completely understanding a paper takes time and effort but I have come across papers that are easy to follow and also easy to reproduce in MATLAB. I've heard that papers are written for those who are already familiar with the particular area. I know that papers these days build up on a lot of literature and hence are very compactly written.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |